Skip to main content


Literary Friday: The Scottish Prisoner

Friday, March 16, 2012


This week I read The Scottish Prisoner by Diana Gabaldon.  She also wrote the wildly popular Outlander series which is my very favorite series of all time. You can read about the series here.

One of the reasons I wanted to get this book is because there is a preview of Written in My Own Heart's Blood,  the eight installment of Outlander, in the back of the book.  I wanted to read this excerpt badly because the seventh book, An Echo in the Bone, ended with a triple cliffhanger!

The Scottish Prisoner is a book about an episode that happened while Jamie was serving out his term as prisoner of war at Helwater when his illegitimate son, William, was a "wee bonnie lad."  Of course Claire was still in the future after the failure at Culloden, so I spent most of the book feeling sorry for Jamie as he deals with his grief over the loss of his beloved wife and unborn child.  Lord John Grey is a major character in this book, but this is not strictly a Lord John Grey novel like others Gabaldon has written.  Lord John's elder brother Hal, the Duke of Pardloe, needs help in a possible court martial case. A manuscript written in Erse, or Scottish Gaelic, needs translating, and Hal sends soldiers to Helwater to retrieve Jamie and bring him to London so he can help with the translation.  The translation was included in several documents written about Major Gerald Siverly; the documents are proof of corruption and of a possible future plot.

But before the soldiers arrive at Helwater, Tobias Quinn, a Jacobite who eludes capture, appears to inform Jamie of a scheme to rally the Irish Jacobites to fight for the cause.  The plan includes an ancient Druid relic, and Jamie wants nothing to do with the cause, politics, or Irish Jacobites.  He has recently been allowed to give young William riding lessons, and he is so grateful for the opportunity that he does not want anything to interfere with spending time with his son.

The manuscript Jamie translates is a story of the Wild Hunt straight from Celtic folklore, yet it is also a coded missive about a new Jacobite rising: a plot that would endanger King George II. Soon Jamie and Lord John set sail for Ireland to question Siverly.  Jamie and Lord John have had a very volatile relationship since Outlander, and the trip to Ireland proves to be a difficult task for the two of them.  Plus Quinn arrives on the scene as a travel companion to further complicate their mission.

My favorite aspect of the book is the Celtic mythology and supernatural elements woven throughout the plot.  It was fun for me to read about Jamie's brush with the mystical realm rather than Claire.  I have a sneaking suspicion that we might see more of this side of Jamie and perhaps an ancient Druid or two in future Outlander books.  Lord John was his usual honorable self, and I enjoyed the parts of the book written from his point of view.  I highly recommend this book to anyone who has read the Outlander and/or Lord John Grey series.  It is a nice Jamie Fraser (and Lord John Grey) fix while waiting for Written in My Own Heart's Blood.

I must say that this year has not been a good reading year so far.  I have read a few good nonfiction books, but I have been in terrible reading slump when it comes to fiction.  Please, if you have any good fiction recommendations, please share them with me.  PLEASE!!!

Until next time...

Happy reading!
Ricki Jill


  1. I am definitely of no use to you since I use you as my reading reference! I'll be watching to see what kind of feed back you get. Have a fabulous weekend.

  2. All my reading is in re: to chickens at the moment so no recommendations. I love anything to do with Scotland though and this sounds so good. Are your girls in to the Hunger Games? My Maddy is going to the midnight showing and is so excited. She even bought a t-shirt today. She loved the books.

  3. a few suggestions reviewed at FHC ~ plus one i'm giving away today if you'd like an irish interest :)
    HaPpY St Patrick's to you today !

  4. Ricki Jill I have read some great books recently and the reviews are coming soon, one is in fact highly rated by Diana Gabaldon herself. I think you read my book review blog so keep an eye open. For now I highly recommend Tiger Hills which I reviewed just yesterday.

  5. Today I went to Barnes & Noble and walked around without a clue. I didn't buy a single book! I should have brought the list I made. The list is named, "Ricki Jill Recommends." :D

  6. I LOVE The Outlander Series~ I'm anxiously awaiting MOHB's release! Triple cliffhanger indeed for EITB. I haven't read any of the Lord John series~ this book did intrigue me when I heard about it. I'll have to take a closer look. Thanks for the recommendation. I did read a fun & quirky book The Matchmaker of Perigord for Food for Thought :)

  7. Have you discovered Canadian author Ami McKay?? The Birth House is excellent one many awards and now she has written The Virgin Cure which I have and it is great.

    My cousin read the Outlander Series and loved it and I have been meaning to start it!
    Happy Sunday Ricki!!
    Pamela ox

  8. OH I mean't to write won not one...but you know that right lol???

  9. Oh, thanks for the book recommendations! I think I got the book I'm reading now from you, "THE LANTERN"? I'm loving it!

  10. SUch a wonderful and deep book, I read it , in italian of course!If you want we can follow also with bloglovin, google+, twitter and facebook?
    Win your favourite jewels from Les Jumelles
    Come back soon to visit my blog, I'll be waiting for you!!
    Cosa mi metto???


Comments are friendly!

Hello, Lovelies!

I'm Ricki Jill. Welcome! I'm honored that you're reading my blog. I enjoy sharing my creative lifestyle @ The Bookish Dilettante. For more information about my blog, please read the Start Here page. Thank-you for stopping by, and I hope you'll consider following me via email.


Follow me on Instagram